by Tijs Besieux, PhD
A few years ago, I led a research team that investigated a bank's corporate culture.
For context: the regulator demanded this piece of work (referred to as a ‘root cause analysis’) after discovering several instances of misconduct. To better understand the ‘why’, a regulator can then ask an independent external party to uncover the root causes of such misconduct, in this instance, resulting from behavioral risk.
I rate this type of work as ‘high-pressure’ because, as a consultant, you’re navigating a tense territory where the bank’s entire C-suite and high-level leaders from the regulator (ultimately acting on behalf of society) operate.
After a month of research, which included 70+ one-on-one interviews, 20+ team observations, a company-wide survey, and desk analysis including thousands of pages of strategy documents (just to name a few sources), our team came to the conclusion (which in itself was another three-day intensive meeting) that the misconduct was driven by three root causes:
(1) A belief that mistakes would hurt one’s career, leading people to shove small errors under the rug,
(2) Sub-optimal decision-making (especially in terms of speed) driven by a culture of consensus and lack of accountability, and
(3) A reward system that promoted individual, short-term sales targets instead of long-term relationship building.
(For anonymity’s sake, the root causes described here are simplified.)
We presented our findings to the executive team, with the CEO sitting at the head of a large, dark-brown wooden rectangular table on the top floor of a stunning building.
(We stood on the other side of the table, as instructed, so between the first C-team member, the Chief HR Officer, and us were three empty chairs.)
For context: in this type of work, the CEO is not looped in at the start or halfway through the analysis to ensure an objective assessment.
And so, when I was done presenting the core findings, the CEO took a long pause, a deep breath, and then looked me straight in the eye and said, “Nothing from this analysis surprises me. Nothing is new to me.” Full stop.
In that split second between the CEO’s comment and my response, a few thoughts went through my mind.
I’m thinking: “That can’t be right; we surfaced insights from deep in the trenches. He can’t possibly know it all!” And “Oh no, we’ve invested so much time and energy to find something he already knew; what a waste!”
But the most stubborn, and least helpful thought was: “I now have to add another insight, say something that is novel to him, so he sees the value of the work we did!”
In these situations, I’ve been lucky enough to have received countless hours of mentoring from top experts in leadership, negotiation, and effective communication over the past 16 years.
And so just as I was about to blurt out an unhelpful response (for instance, by trying to add another insight that might actually surprise him...), I realized that his response was actually the perfect gift to spark a provocative yet constructive dialogue.
I can’t know for sure why he responded that way, but at the time I weighed three potential reasons:
(1) As a CEO, he’s being paid to be in control. And so a CEO who explicitly says “Well, that surprises me!”, or “Well, that caught me off guard”, might be perceived as not doing a proper job, especially in a context where the regulator is involved.
(2) He wasn’t fond of our findings, and made that comment to diminish the value of the research and its conclusions.
(3) He in fact already knew all of this, and genuinely felt like there were no surprises at all. Now keep in mind that in a report like this, we use redacted quotes from front-line employees, specific behavioral observations of how teams meet, and granular details from HR policies.
My thinking at the time was that he made the comment mainly for reason #1: he did not want to come across as failing at his job.
And so I knew that, in my response, I wanted to confront him as a CEO, but I needed to do so without breaking our fragile relationship.
So, I replied:
“I appreciate that you recognize the important parts of the analysis (here I decided to paraphrase the ‘nothing is new to me’ statement because that can lead to an unproductive cycle of trying to point out details that he possibly couldn’t know, which doesn’t help anyone solve actual problems).
“And I’m grateful to everyone here for taking the time to listen to our findings (I said this specifically to broaden the dialogue and ease the 1:1 tension between the CEO and me that otherwise could have dominated the remainder of the session), and I’m sure many of you have follow-up questions for which we have plenty of time.
“But for now I’d like to take some time to reflect on a question which I think is fundamental, a question that arises from the first feedback of the CEO (here I’m not naming it as a ‘comment’ or a ‘judgment’ of the CEO, but as ‘feedback’, a term that is neutral).
“If the report contains mainly findings that are already known, and if you appreciate their importance, then why has the organization not moved yet from problem to solution?” (Here I’m not saying ‘you’, I’m deliberately using ‘organization’ at first to make it more neutral; in the following sessions we drilled it down to the accountability of the executive committee.)
Now I’m sure there are more productive replies I could have given, but I also know there are many more unproductive replies that I could have given, such as trying to cite additional findings in an attempt to prove to the CEO that our report was ‘useful’ from his point of view.
Because that would not be the goal of the report, but rather my own ego getting in the way, trying to ‘please’ the CEO.
Here’s what happened: in follow-up to my response, other members of the executive committee stepped in and did two things mainly:
(1) they downplayed the “the report doesn’t contain anything new” statement by explicitly mentioning how they had not realized that some root causes shaped employee behavior that caused specific risks like mis-selling, and
(2) they empathized with the idea that no action had been taken yet, which they saw as their own flaw and even a confirmation of how deeply rooted that lack of accountability was.
As I observed and encouraged the candidness of the dialogue, the CEO stepped in again and said: “Well, okay, I can see that this report holds a powerful mirror to us as a team, and it’s up to us to take the first step forward, so let’s focus on what we can do to step into the solution space.”
Reflecting on this situation, it still feels to me like one of those decisive moments where your career could have gone south.
If I had responded “It’s impossible to know all the details from the report”, or if I had responded “Okay so here’s another detail you perhaps don’t know yet”, the entire dynamic and power-balance could have shifted, damaging the relationship we were building.
In consulting, trust is the one and only currency, and it compounds over time.
My main learning was twofold:
(1) there is always a space between action and reaction, and what feels like eternity is often just a few seconds, and
(2) there is often a gap between what people say and why they say it, and in your response, you can make all the difference by focusing on the underlying why in a productive way.